Monday, December 21, 2009

What The Different Between Microsuede

in favor of the rights over their own bodies ... Presentation + review

[ must be very attentive to the descenlace to be in the next months all that has been happening in different regions of the country on the barrage of penalties for the eruption of pregnancy (abortion). It would appear that we envidenciando action encapsulation and, therefore, of the collapse of what has been a triumph auténtito Mexican democracy, if we consider the latter to the invention of a shared order between subjects (men and women), between abstract entities. In this regard, we must keep an eye to the article published a few weeks ago Miguel Carbonell.]
The NHRC and abortion
Miguel Carbonell
El Universal, 17 December 2009

In modern democratic societies live many different ways of understanding and evaluating social phenomena. Pluralism seems to be the rule in a democracy, unlike what happens with authoritarian and dictatorial systems, in which there is only one set of values.
In some subjects may be that this pluralism is extreme, resulting in open positions and even contradictory, at times, irreconcilable. How can we resolve such views? The most advanced countries usually take up their constitutional courts such dilemmas of great significance, so that judges are to decide on the issue, based on law and not on personal convictions that could have each of them.
This comes about because a few days ago, in my capacity as a member of the Advisory Board of the NHRC, I made a formal request to the new president to exercise its legal authority to bring an action challenging the constitutionality of local laws criminalization of abortion. I must say that the president of the National Commission was attentive and responsive, being in it would study the issue. Later made a statement to the media stating that the position of the National Human Rights Commission would be based on what was decided by the Supreme Court's last year in connection with the decriminalization of abortion DF. To be consistent with that view is only feasible would be to present the claim of unconstitutionality, as the opinion of the Court is precisely contrary to what they have been regulated for 17 states.
Never mind the personal convictions of Dr. Raul Plascencia or members of the Advisory Board of the NHRC. The advantage of bringing the issue before the Supreme Court's is that it asks a referee, with the neutrality that is a decision based in law and rule of living together, decide how to protect the rights at stake. Plascencia said it clearly: it finds "an institutional stance." Bravo for that.
When former president the National Human Rights Commission Dr. José Luis Soberanes, filed a constitutional motion against the reform of the DF on abortion, I was against it. Over time, however, I must admit that the decision to Soberanes had several positive effects, because it allowed a serious and informed debate on a topic that is of interest to all who live in Mexico. And for the first time in many years saw a substantive discussion at the plenary of the Supreme Court on the scope of fundamental rights in question. Moreover, the decision drafted by the Minister José Ramón Cossio was successful in general terms and allows Mexico to join a powerful international movement on women's rights. With this decision we all win.
When such sensitive issues as abortion, the worst thing you can do is dismiss the views of those who think like us. We must make an effort to step into the shoes of another, based on the idea that almost all participants in the debate do so in good faith. It is unfair to impose ideological options using state power to legislate. Are best judges that, based solely on legal grounds, solve the problem. The sore point is that for the Supreme Court to act, should be urged to do so by a legitimate body. Hence my request to the chairman of the NHRC. He
is the only one within the National Human Rights Commission may decide. Advisory Board members can and should express our point of view, for that we were appointed by the Senate. But the law does rest the full weight of the decision, for better or for worse, in the person of the President of the Commission. Following the decision taken, we can certainly observe closely how far the commitment to the rights of all Raul Plascencia. It is the first real test of their newly opened office. Hopefully, the knowledge advantage. The ball is in their court, president. Researcher
www.miguelcarbonell.com
IIJ-UNAM