A note to subscribe to our" optimistic "educational
Dear friends, this was the read text in the presentation of the Metapolítica yesterday night. Would be of interest to you (Israel Covarrubias)
Who cares education in Mexico?
(Presentation No. 64. Metapolítica journal, June 23, 2009, House of Time UAM)
Throughout the twentieth century, the defining feature of democratic political system as we know, what was the incorporation of the masses under different policy (in primis, through mass parties) to politicize society (subjective) and, together, to pretend to socialize democracy and politics, in a game of return: "top down" and "bottom up." However, this would not be possible without the invention of a public (supposedly neutral) to be born as a guarantor of individual liberties and political rights, taking shape in the liberal state of law, then returned total (when the state becomes the exception and make war), then social for the second time, then again liberal and, more recently, absent: call failed, collapsed, in crisis, captured, and so on.
It is worth noting here, however, is that the state under the dynamics of democratic regime (elections, pluralism, dissent, participation, etc.), [1] enrolled at the present time the category of political hope (expectation) in the sense of inculcating citizens with the belief (by aim was to politicize the political subjectivity and subjectivism) that the State, only he, in his absolute solitude, be responsible or occupy, through the triple action socialization, integration and education, improvement of material conditions (health, work, housing) and the production of symbolic resources (education, that is, generate their own opinions, a profile of national culture, law, authority, etc.) of individuals and society as a whole.
From the above mentioned, leads to two simplistic arguments. The first, public life of democracy is the result of an ongoing conflict, not solved in the least, between the proliferation of the needs (and therefore do not think only in the material), the means to achieve them (those whom the State has sought to meet with different institutional areas) and the impact of the results obtained at the level of the subject's experience (generally below expectations in society by politics and its systems of representation). The second, and that is the issue that now brings us together, has to do with the speeds, highs and lows and always incomplete dynamic where, at least in Mexico, has set up a perverse logic that public education is (or at least was), by being granted the state level, the central lever of development and democracy in our country.
In this sense, perhaps one of the points we could leave on the table for potential discussion is the idea that the State in Mexico historically instituted a mechanism for exchanging at least with respect to the institutional architecture that supports basic education: promises trust (legitimacy), [2] ie a sort of symbolic sale and real aspirations to return to public education, [3] a desirable. But something back to education desirable presupposes do, or act, in the order of expectation, not that of experience, and thereby transformed it into a sort of "not yet." So the question is: how much longer you can still become a reality?, How long basic education can enable the formation of an original social ethos, ie the construction of a shared personality meet at a single time and place individuality capable of producing symbolic resources (see the society in which they live, social position, space and time which is, etc.), in a word company producing experience and expertise of state, both in sense democratic? And I think the question of individuality in both subjectivities, that is, every step of change in each school, beginning with the revaluation of the place of teacher and student, the knowledge necessary and sufficient, conditions for the material and immaterial labor teachers, etc.. In this way, is the text of Bonifacio Barba Box and Margarita Zorrilla Fierro. While it would have to ask, with a federal government as it is now, we can think of a profound change of subjectivities that make up the school in particular with regard to issues of teaching there in the classroom, regarding updating the out of date? Perhaps here the answer is negative. [4]
I think what we're seeing and experiencing today in the field of basic education in our country is the final fall of the postponement of the good (or bad) intentions of those who have addressed the interests of many contained in within the basic education system to a better time.
In his work, Alba Martínez Olivé (p. 33), clearly states:
is no longer possible or wise to postpone a national debate, democratic, high view, the basic proposals and areas for analysis and input, not conducive to a more short-term reform, to continue burdening teachers and pupils difficult learning by excessive or inappropriate content, but a solid rethinking the meaning of essential basics in education, rediscover and refine the values \u200b\u200bthat gave rise to the Mexican public education, recognize what must remain in this century and modify or eliminate what is not useful.
Then, it is likely that the question "Who cares about education in Mexico? he responds with another question that is not responding, but wishes to indicate the beginning of the problem we have in hand today, what good show possible directions on education for the coming months and years if the state government (in political and institutional) our country the word has lost its density horizon to give place to the word crisis? And not just his sense that "something is happening" in reverse to the process of generating expectations (it must be said: horizon and expectations go hand), but rather in the sense that without a minimum notion of basic education as ethics, as a form of society, there is little that can advance the promise and no improvement, at least to compromise. You need to remember that our basic education system is heir to both the historical inertia of the lesser evil, whose translation is now semi-state effort to mediate an education (see agreement Elba Esther Gordillo and Televisa recently), and the forms feudalisation change [5] education through which represented the SNTE. Pointed precisely in the last nine years.
Therefore, where does this lead us? A point, discussing and thinking about education as a state, specifically, as the crucial problem of democratic statehood. To begin, we should ask what to correct, change, that close to the erosion of confidence subject to the State. Too many promises were not kept of the Mexican State to subject and from a society increasingly precarious. Al not keep such promises (for example, does education have to open a door to future time or simply the end to close?), we would be in the presence of a company with a lot of fatigue only relies on the state [6] it costs society enormities believe (because that's the point of believing, knitting sense with what the State says, does not say, does not). Therefore, it is worth asking, as a second Gino reflection: how can detect the current time in our society to a person in whom we place our trust, how someone becomes capable of being respectable [authority ] to the point of becoming our confident, how can the state take part in it, especially if we think that the present generations perspective of the national basic education system are, like it or not to accept the citizenship of the future of Mexico? [7] In this sense, the work of Ynclán and Elvia Gabriela Zúñiga (from the results of a focus group reflexive), it seems indicative of this problem: a series of witness interviews about the types of leadership in Inside the schools, the particular way of relating to parents and teachers, between the latter and the directors and among them with students. In the end, what can be inferred from this work involved with the reserves, are most frequent perceptions (the authoritarian legacies) about the state, institution and education. What branch is it? Evidence, in the opinion of the authors, "undemocratic and authoritarian practices that breed in the relationship and dealing with students in classroom work and are not exclusive to them" (p. 41).
On the other hand, a point that can allow us to understand the issue of trust is suggested to note the role of informal areas within the institutional form that we have in the structure of basic education. For example, both the realism in form of production decisions and the non-linkage of many sectors of society about public education as a right. [8] The question is: How demanding or receiving? Indeed, the state has tried to build minimal areas of equality along the horizon of society, however, these areas are not only successful if we like figure, as cover. This is the problem, instead of instituting a logic of cooperation, is to move forward, no clear plan and no options statehood society towards a more imaginary real education and training notions of order, law and authority. Perhaps precisely why our country, the word law has ceased to be a crucial signifier of social life. Is not public school who would be forced to have this social translation, a translation of every day?
In conclusion, it is worth discussing the issue of basic education in the extension of the triple problem actually expresses the Mexican state: the lack of integration in the economic realm (how long it will continue opposing the state to market?) in the field of social relations and in the field of justice. As such it appears that the tentative conclusion of the dossier on education is: the State has not done to understand their society, subjects that way, and it does not seem to like doing, when in reality it is an urgent requirement. Otherwise, you may continue succeeding in the near future education reforms without cover or represent the most basic of all: the level of experience, meaning, of coexistence, because the State provided the state has been only in a series of technical responses that do not cover the debts of the company, much less the social desire to feel represented by someone so that, in fact, be born a notion and practice of "community" differently, perhaps democracy.
[1] Although the Mexican case, we must add that the adjective "democratic" can be interpreted as the first of many absences from the political system, political system, properly speaking, and supposedly once powerful PRI state.
[2] As the mafia! As the central subject of the sale of protection, the centrality of mafia organizations, is trust (as a value, obviously informal.)
[3] Beyond that, indeed, is the only option on the horizon precarious for millions of Mexicans.
[4] A diagnosis on the role of the inactual update is contained in the article by Germain Cervantes Ayala.
[5] worth a comment: change and reform are not synonymous. That is, the various reforms the system of basic education reform are based on something already established, but that is no guarantee that in reality changes.
[6] concern is not free from several institutional fronts in relation to the issue of vote-nullifying the vote-no vote, another example: the hysterical actions and systematic harassment of the country's credit system delays payment of different types of credit in a general situation of economic crisis. Are not you supposed, I think, the credit is based on mutual trust of the parties? Do not forget that trust is central to understanding the institutional dynamics, is, again, an informal appeal.
[7] should be clear that there are two types of trust, a systemic and other biographical. The first is that it gives the State or that it produces (legitimacy), the second has its rationale in some of the principles governing the education system: ethics, solidarity, harmony, life in society building and so on.
[8] I sense that in these coordinates are, subject to the distance that separates them, with the work of Christopher Charles Martin and put on one side, and Claudia Santizo on the other.
0 comments:
Post a Comment